At this year’s AMA Symposium for the Marketing of Higher Education, a poll before the awareness panel split the room in half on whether awareness budgets had changed in the past 18 months. Asked who was hardest to convince, the audience named the CFO and the president. Later that day, David Jewell, former CFO and chief operating officer of Cleveland State University, told the audience that the sector has never had a more informed consumer. In more than twenty years in the industry, he said, he had never seen this much uncertainty.
I’ve worked in higher education marketing, in-house and agency side, since 2005, and as I left the symposium it hit me that every program a college offers now has to prove its worth to three audiences at once: the family deciding whether to enroll, the CFO deciding whether to fund, and a federal government that has started measuring outcomes by program.
For your higher education marketing to work in 2027, you’ll need to put the same proof in front of all three audiences.
Families judge a program by what its graduates bring home
The decision to enroll is often made at a kitchen table. Mandy Heil of Arizona Western College, speaking on the panel “Defending Brand Awareness and Reputation Inside a Performance-Obsessed Institution,” described how top-of-funnel brand and program messaging has to reach the parents, grandparents, and spouses who help a prospective student decide, because in her community it’s often the whole family who supports that choice. She also described students who grew up near the college and told the outreach team they wanted a technical school for welding, without knowing the college already offered it. Those families were making one of the biggest decisions of their lives without knowing a program was right in front of them.
I’ve seen the other side of that decision too. Our work with one of our biggest career college clients took me to several campuses for video shoots, where graduates told me about advancing professionally in ways that made them and their families proud. Each of those graduates took a story home, and that story, told by a family about a program, is what the next family hears. But the story is only as strong as the result the program delivers.
Recent enrollment data points in the same direction. The National Student Clearinghouse’s preliminary fall 2026 numbers show undergraduate growth slowing to 0.6 percent from 2.4 percent a year earlier, with community colleges driving the increase while four-year enrollment held roughly flat. Certificates were the fastest-growing credential this spring, up 10.2 percent, while four-year computer science enrollment fell 12.4 percent this fall, which may reflect students reacting to a tighter entry-level job market.
The pool of future students is shrinking too. The Western Interstate Commission for Higher Education projects that high school graduates peaked in 2025 and will fall 13 percent by 2041. In Gallup and Lumina Foundation’s 2026 poll, only 38 percent of Americans say they have a great deal or quite a lot of confidence in higher education. Cost and value is the reason they cite most, and analysts say that reflects a growing expectation that colleges show the value they deliver.
Only 38 percent of Americans have a great deal or quite a lot of confidence in higher education.
Gallup and Lumina Foundation, 2026
CFOs fund the programs that prove a return
Jewell put it bluntly: it’s easy to grow enrollment and lose money once discounting is counted, and few provosts can name the five programs that make money and the five that lose it. I’ve sat through plenty of budget meetings feeling like the person across the table was working from a different playbook, so it was useful to hear a CFO say what he needs. He wants to know whether a program produces a result worth what it costs. Strip away the spreadsheet and that’s also the family’s question.
Two stories from the symposium show what happens when a marketer does and does not bring the answer. Jeff Holman, CMO and brand director at the University of Florida’s Warrington College of Business, walked into a CFO meeting with a high-level strategy for a reputation campaign. The CFO wanted every tactic and a guaranteed outcome, the conversation went sideways, and the campaign went unfunded. Looking back, Holman said a phased investment with milestones would have landed better.
Bill Campbell, who spent 14 years at Chatham University as VP of marketing and later VP of operations, got a yes on a pricing pilot for a graduate program because he arrived with the enrollment projection, the cost of delivering it, and a one-year window. The capacity already existed, so the pilot added no expense. Both CFOs had the same instinct, but the yes went to the marketer who answered the question before it was asked.
Federal aid now depends on graduate earnings
The Department of Education announced its final earnings rule on June 29, and the provisions took effect July 1. Each year, the Department will compare the median earnings of an undergraduate program’s completers, measured four years after they finish, with the median for working adults aged 25 to 34 who hold only a high school diploma. Graduate programs are held to the median for bachelor’s degree holders. A program that fails in two of three consecutive years loses Direct Loan eligibility.
A program that fails in two of three consecutive years loses Direct Loan eligibility.
U.S. Department of Education final earnings rule, effective July 1
The first calculations arrive in early 2027, and the earliest a program can be designated low-earning is the 2028-29 award year, which starts in July 2028. A first failure matters sooner than that. The Department warns the institution, and institutions must warn current and prospective students whenever the Department notifies them that a program could lose federal aid. That notice will reach the same students your campaigns are trying to reach. An institution that takes no action after a first failure cannot later choose either of its two options: pulling the program from Direct Loans for at least five award years, or closing it through a teach-out. Career colleges have worked under a version of this test for years, and the rest of higher education is catching up.
The pressure lands hardest on the fastest-growing credential. NPR reported that undergraduate certificates are a major red flag in the Department’s earnings data: a quarter of the students in those programs attend one that would likely fail the test. Workforce Pell, which started this summer, opens federal aid to programs as short as eight weeks. So a certificate is a growth bet and a liability at the same time. Workforce Pell programs face a separate standard: 70 percent completion, 70 percent job placement, and earnings gains that cover tuition, with each state’s governor approving the program first. A Workforce Pell program loses eligibility the first year it misses the earnings standard. A marketer should know which of their certificates clear those bars before putting a dollar behind any of them.
Build your outcome numbers before Washington publishes its own
This puts marketers in an unusual position. We’re the people on campus who already know how to find an audience, read its behavior, and tell a story that moves it. The question all three audiences are asking requires that skill set, pointed inward.
Start with the outcome data on every program you market: completion, placement, and earnings, by program, in a form a parent could read. Most of it already sits on campus, in accreditation filings and career services databases. Institutions also had to file program-level completion and cost data with the Department by October 1, so that filing is either done or overdue. The federal earnings measure runs four years behind, so for a program enrolling students this fall, the numbers you can show families today are your own completion and placement results, labeled with the year they cover.
Waiting for the Department’s number is the wrong plan for the 2027 budget, because the first calculation lands in early 2027 and covers graduates who finished years ago. Ask institutional research for an estimate now: where each certificate and degree program’s graduate earnings sit against the Department’s benchmark for working adults aged 25 to 34 with a high school diploma. Alumni wage surveys can supply a rough answer, and rough is enough to sort programs into clearly above the line, close to it, and below it. Mark it as an estimate every time it appears.
If the numbers are strong, build the story around them and put it in the family’s hands before the enrollment conversation starts. Level’s 2026 Higher Education Performance Benchmarks Report shows what a clear outcome story is worth. Media cost per enrolled student was $1,186 for trades programs and $4,016 for liberal arts, a 3.4x difference. The report reads it as a clarity story: trades programs answer the job title, salary, and time-to-credential question on the first page, and most liberal arts programs do not. The data covers adult learner, career-technical, and online programs, not traditional undergraduate or residential four-year programs, and it compares program categories without testing outcome messaging directly.
Media cost per enrolled student: $1,186 for trades programs vs. $4,016 for liberal arts, a 3.4x difference.
Level’s 2026 Higher Education Performance Benchmarks Report (adult learner, career-technical, and online programs)
If the numbers are weak, that’s valuable information. Carry it to the people who can fix the program instead of spending more to recruit for it.
Marketers who show up to budget meetings with evidence stop being a line item in the CFO’s spreadsheet and start helping fill it in.
Bring four answers to your 2027 higher education marketing budget meeting
Which programs get awareness dollars. The ones with strong outcomes that families haven’t heard of. Market research tells you which programs people don’t know exist; outcome data tells you which ones deserve to be known. Awareness spend on a program that fails the earnings test is money spent recruiting students into a problem.
Which metrics sit next to enrollment. Awareness and engagement, reported in the same dashboard as applications and starts. One panelist found that counting awareness-only spend inside performance formulas made the numbers look worse than they were, and rebuilt the reporting to show both. Report cost per start by program, net of discounting, so the CFO sees what the marketer sees.
What milestone structure to ask for. A multi-year window with checkpoints, since speakers described digital campaigns needing six to nine months to show lift. One favored three-year funding tied to metrics with a hard review at the end. Propose the checkpoints yourself. A CFO who hears “here is what you will see at month six, twelve, and eighteen” is hearing accountability, which is what Holman’s unfunded reputation campaign was missing.
Which outcomes to put in front of families. Completion, placement, and earnings for each program, in plain language, on the program page and in the hands of the admissions team. The family at the table will ask anyway. Better they get the answer from you.
Two readings arrive in early 2027: the Clearinghouse’s final fall 2026 enrollment data in January, and the Department’s first earnings calculations. Programs that already have their own outcome numbers will have something to say when both land.
If you want a second read before then, Level’s higher education team can map your enrollment marketing performance against the benchmarks in our report and show which programs to put your next dollar behind. Request a custom benchmark audit.